I think this is an incredibly well-made and important point.
The position taught is the accepted technique.
Depending on body type, hand size, comfort, and a bunch of other things, adjustments can and should be made.
Thanks, madden.
Yes, totally! Glad you shared all that. What weāre shooting for is maximum ability+ease to minimum effort, the usual guidelines only go so far. Everyone, including me, has to find the sweet spot between shoulder, elbow and wrist placement and angle by experimenting.
I am having similar problems with playing major and minor arpeggios. I am trying to train my pinky finger to play along. Its not being a teem player. In a major, I manage the root, the third, the fifth, but as I try to use my pinky on the octave, it usually makes a twang. Same thing with the minors. I am having fun playing, but I want to keep improving as I go along. Any suggestions on fingering technique?
well dang this is a little off-topic but, some of the responses are like 3 inches long on my screen and I have a big screen lol
Is your pinky reaching to the end (ish) of the fret, or are you maybe not stretching far enough? Twangs/rattles/etc. are usually either a location thing, or a pressure thing. If you are aiming for the right part of the fret, itās just a matter of getting your pinky to apply a wee bit more pressure (not more than you need for a clean tone). Does that help?
You can always change the scale of the page in your browser to make text bigger or smaller if you preferā¦ if Iām understanding you right?
no but Iām just saying there called comments for a reason: there short and I have my screen set to normal and I have a monitor that 22 inch by 13 inch (22 wide 13 from top to bottom)
Oh, gotcha. Well you can always skim or not read anything you want! But itās a forum, people are gonna talk, sometimes at length.
When playing notes with my pinky, my hand gets all crazy as shown. Sometimes I try and just place all my fingers on the string, to try and keep them low. Since they are lower notes (higher on the neck) they arenāt changing the sound.
Is this not mentioned as a way to tame the crazy fingers because itās a bad habit?
No. Thereās nothing wrong with that. If I understand what your saying, youāre just muting the strings youāre not playing by doing that and thatās a good thing.
Well, itās frets above the note I am playing.
But module 4, lesson 3, part 2 kind of covers this a bit too. Should have been watching the videos instead of browsing the forums!
Hey @cbaray, that sounds good to me! I actually talk about that in this video (in the Level 2 exercise):
Josh,
I watched your finger exercise video, and started doing your finger exercise. At first my fingers dragged themselves over the fretboard, arthritis not helping. Iām now getting good fretting with no buzz my fingers also feel more supple. I didnāhave problem though, it felt more like fingering the lovely bagpipes. The instrument of my youth. Cant beat the drones.
Glad those exercises are helping! I still do them too!