I’ve been working on this one whilst going through the B2B modules…Didnt have my camera available to record me playing so just added some pics.
To he honest, I found this one really tough, I couldn’t seem to really nail the timing, but I’ll revisit from time to time and hopefully as I move through the course it’ll improve
@Liffguard
Love that song and a great cover. Nothing wrong with using Karaoke version for the backing track. I have an account with them and I’ll use that version when I can’t fully remove the bass line with the tools I have. Great performance.
I wouldn’t worry about that at all - I have done the same! In fact, most of the times, these are good versions (very, very close to the original), and much cleaner to work with if you want to record a cover! Good job here! Maybe I wouldn’t tap out the beats on a string during the “tacet” parts - that might get you in trouble at some point…
Willie Watson is a founding member of Old Crow Medicine Show, and he plays also with Dave Rawlings and Gillian Welch with Dave Rawlings Machine. That’s certainly because he’s a member of this famous crew that I discovered Willie Watson, thanks to the Youtube suggestions
I like this song, especially this live version which is quite minimal. I decided to try to add my bass line. I had to keep it very minimal, very “open” to keep the spirit of the song. It’s all in the timing, droning and muting.
Greenie in EADG straight into the Bass POD Pro. This time I didn’t use the foam, because I wanted a long sustain to fill the empty parts. So, to keep some consistency with my usual country bass tone and considering that the foam makes Greenie sound more dark, I rolled down the Tone pot to 5.
Hey @Liffguard,
Nice job on your cover, good right hand finger crossing, liked the tone and you look very focused.
I agree with Joerg with regards to tapping fingers on strings, but we are all different and if this works for you👍
Cheers Brian
Nice first up cover @MattHinchliffe,
Fitted nicely, timing was ok, just a couple spots around the 1.40m to 1.50m.
Maybe just add a bit more bass into the mix👍It was a little overwhelmed in a couple of spots😎
Another thing to keep in mind is we are always more self critical, what you think would probably not even be noticed by the audience (US)
I look back over the covers I’ve done and in reflection think I could have done this better or why didn’t I pick that up, in the end it doesn’t matter because we are improving all the time.
Keep up the good work,
Cheers Brian
Thanks for that review Brian, that really helps. I’m am pleased with it overall and I can see my progress. Your right about being overly critical…I’m very much my own worst critic…I do a lot of my recording through headphones as well, so I seem much more aware of any slight issues. I usually like to listen back to the final mix in the car :). I’ll look boosting the bass a bit as well… The whole recording/mixing etc is a new to me
Hey Matt @MattHinchliffe,
It was new to me when I started here last year, the guys on the forum are really helpful and provide great feedback to help us improve our playing etc.
As I said earlier, I look back at my playing on the first covers I did and what I’m doing now and I see the big improvements in both my recording and my playing
Cheers Brian
Nice job @Liffguard I had that song on my list of covers to do, but I don’t think I could do it any better than you did it. I only wish I could have heard a little more volume on the backing track, but otherwise it was splendid.
Hey @MattHinchliffe Matthew there’s nothing wrong with just doing a slide show with your cover. You sounded great and the timing was great. You stayed in the groove the entire song, and that’s the most important thing.
Nice job @terb. I don’t normally like your choice of music, but this was quite enjoyable. I really liked the song and your bass line. You always do such a magnificent job of laying down a great groove. I’m still amazed at how well you to this while sitting down LOL. I couldn’t do it.
That tone is perfect for this song, I like Greenie rolled off like that. I like where the bass is sitting in the mix too.
Technique-wise you are demonstrating very good form in the video too, some serious pinky reach there
It kind of sounds like the bass is getting some very light phasing at times in the sustain, not sure where that is coming from - might just be some killer color that the bass just has. I love it.
Another great cover @terb Laurent! I liked the song, it kind of reminded me of some James Taylor material back in his early years. Great tone out of Greenie.