Playing a G&L Fallout short scale and have a tuning question. The machine heads are a high enough ratio (maybe 20:1?) that it makes keeping the string tuned to the sweet spot a challenge. Pass it, back up. Too much, go back the other way. You know the drill.
I changed the tuners on my BB734 and wasn’t impressed with the lack of real improvement. I went from 20:1 to 28:1 but it should’ve been close to 40:1 in my opinion to have made any real difference.
I have this on a few of my basses and 2 guitars. It’s one of the most satisfying tuning especially on B string. My only gripe is that they hold tunes really well so adjustment is not happening as often as I would like,
The only downside I can foresee with them is they’re about twice as heavy as Hipshot USA UltraLites. This might be a problem on some basses prone to neck dive.
I’ve got UltraLites on both of my Mayones and on my Sire U5.
My Cutlass, Sire M5, and Sire V8 all have great stock tuners that are lightweight and rock-solid, so no need for anything else.
I have USA Ultralites on my SBV (they are slightly neck heavy so it’s a nice upgrade). Other Yamahas basses I have always kept stock as Yamaha tuners are usually great.
Guitars, I always swap out for Gotoh Magnum locking tuners in various styles. Just so much more convenient.