Should I return my StingRay 50th Anniversary bass?

Badasses, I could use your advice! I’ve been playing for almost two years. I have zero talent, but absolutely love playing and have thoroughly enjoyed Josh’s curriculum and the BassBuzz community.

My only bass has been a Yamaha BB, which I bought new for about $300. I have no complaints about it and it has served me well. I can honestly say I had never been afflicted by Gear Acquisition Syndrome. But all that changed when the nefarious social media algorithms began telling me I needed the molten gold 50th anniversary StingRay. I bought that obscenely expensive bass.

It’s an absolute beauty and has such a distinctive finish. I love everything about it, except for one thing: the tone. It seems unusually bright and brassy. I’ve tinkered with the EQ controls, of course. That helps to a degree, but I still don’t love the tone. For the sake of comparison, I’ve played a two or three other StingRays at the my local Guitar Center. They have brighter tones than my passive Yahama, but have significantly warmer tones than my StingRay.

I’ve had the bass three or four weeks now and have to make a decision soon about whether I want to return it and get my money back.

My instructor said, “If you’re going to spend that much money on a bass, you should love the way it looks AND love the way it sounds.” He noted that the ebony fretboard and the stainless steel frets are likely adding to the brighter tone, in comparison to other active basses I’ve tried.

My only amp is a Rumble 40. The instructor suggested that the bass might sound warmer on a better amp. (I’ll take it to Guitar Center in the next few days and try out some other amps.)

I’m torn. I don’t want to keep the bass if I’ve never going to embrace the tone. (But maybe there’s a way to get it to sound the way I want.) At the same time, I love everything else about this StingRay and it’ll break my heart if I return it.

Any advice or words of wisdom will be greatly appreciated.

Randall

10 Likes

Obvious question. Have you tried different strings? That’s going to make potentially a big difference. Surprised your instructor didn’t mention that versus fingerboard material / stainless steel frets (not a big factor tbh)

I play La Bella Low Tension Flats on my main bass. If I put on a set of Round Wound DR High Beams for example, then totally different sound.

10 Likes

That’s really hard to answer. If you’re a collector, it might be nice to have it just for that sake, but that’s a lot of money to just have a bass sit around in a case. The gold bridge is probably could be adding to it a bit, but I wouldn’t think it’d be appreciably brighter than the regular chrome bridges.

You can try changing the strings for something that’s less bright from a different line or brand. Maybe even flats or tapes. I’ve got the Hybrid Slinky rounds on my P bass right now and they’re definitely brighter than I usually like. Kind of hoping they mellow out a bit with continued playing. Those share the same D and G strings of the Super Slinkies that come on the 50th, while the E and A strings are from the Regular Slinky pack.

What other StingRays were you trying? It might be worth researching those and comparing what components are different. Otherwise, I’d probably trade it for something else. You can get a DarkRay and get some cash back. Maybe even upgrade the amp with the difference.

4 Likes

Thanks for the thoughtful reply, Barney. Much appreciated. I have not tried different strings. That’s an excellent suggestion. (I’m not sure if switching strings would nullify the return policy. I’ll investigate.) Thanks again.

3 Likes

I’ve done it before. Just don’t tell them. Keep the old strings. Try new ones and if it doesn’t work carefully put the old ones back on and return the bass. All good.

10 Likes

Thank you, Kamikos. That’s wonderful food for thought. The other StingRays I’ve played also had active pre-amps, but were used and definitely lower end models than the molten gold. Thanks again. I really appreciate your comments.

2 Likes

strings and pickups have the most affect on the tone.

Do you play it in a mix? Because that brassiness punches through and may sound different when in a mix with other instruments.

But definitely strings.

3 Likes

Try other strings for sure. One thing I’ll add; when I bought my Sire Z3 (a SR clone) I thought basically the same thing you are. It’s a entirely different sound than what I was used to from my J and P basses. I found some stuff played on a SR and when I tried it out, it sounded awesome. Now I dig it for what it does in that realm.

3 Likes

The first thing to try is definitely new strings. But if they don’t significantly move you to the “OMFG! I’m in love!!!” stage, then return that thing ASAP.

It seems time is of the essence in this equation, so:

  1. Change strings as soon as you can
  2. Keep the old ones (if that makes you more comfortable)
  3. Try the bass out immediately

That said, be aware that brand new strings will sound their brightest when they’re first put on. It takes playing them in to lose the new-string edginess that some love and some hate.

Also, a Fender Rumble 40 isn’t going to make your bass sound bright. That’s not a thing.

Finally, don’t feel compelled to keep that bass if it doesn’t excite you. GAS and algorithms be damned: the latest/greatest shiny new thing ain’t all that great if you don’t feel it and hear it. Trust your ears. Chances are your wallet will thank you.

3 Likes

You don’t specify where you got the bass, but if it was Guitar Cemter like the other ones you tried, you get 45 days to return it. If you change the strings, and I suggest you do, don’t cut the old ones off. Just unwind them and gently straighten the ends enough to thread them back through the bridge. You can then coil them up and keep in a bag or something. Restring it with those if you return it.

You can do the same for the new ones if you do return and reuse them on whatever you end up replacing it with assuming the headstock is similar measurements for the strings.

You mention the other Rays you liked were lower end models. I see the newer MM 50th and, DarkRay, etc are neodymium magnets in the pickups. The others are very likely either ceramic or alnico, as are just about very guitar and bass pickup on the market, even high-end ones. Neos are kind of rare from what I’ve seen. That can change the tone, too. Neos are typically kind of bright and clear. Maybe that’s what you don’t like.

3 Likes

Wow! That thing is beautiful!

4 Likes

New strings for sure. Even when you return it you will have an extra set that will eventually get used. I save all my old strings and have the last set of Rotosounds purchased in 1986. They probably would sound the same to me anyway being nearly deaf.

3 Likes

It’s time for me to step in, :joy:

First thing first, that’s a killer looking bass. I’ve been eyeing the Liquid Gold version simply because, I like to stay more under the radar :rofl:

I know exactly how you feel. I went through that with my NeckThrough Stingray. At the time I was trying to keep the crispiness in check. But let me first tell you about this phenomenon, your taste will change, it goes through its cycle, today it’s round wound bright, crisps, and full of punch, next week it would be thumpy, and warm, follow by the dead mute-y tone, then you discover the beauty of Joe Dart and love his string choice of mid forward flats.

Before you know it, you miss the bright, crisps, and full of punch of the signature Stingray. Not only that you’d start wanting even more brightness because in the mix you standout like the feature instrument in the band. If and when that time comes for you then Gold string by Optima is your next GAS.

Ok this is what I did with my NeckThrough, I put the D’Addario Tapewound on it. At the time it was the rage for me, it sits between Round and Flats, has enough brightness and feels great.

Here’s some sound sample of the different TapeWound, the black string are D’Addario and the Fender Fretless has the La Bella White Gold TapeWound.


Keep in mind you can have it all when you have brightness, it’s so expressive, you can shut that down with a little fretting control as well as plugging control, the ghost note sounds crisps and well defined. Check out this “hooker” song from Pretty Woman. I put the brightest set of string on and this is Maple neck, so the brightness is Maxed.

Also this one for another example. The purple Bronco has RayRoss Saddleless bridge as well as Strat pickup, both can bring up sparkle like nobody business but it’s also so much fun to play.

Another option is to go with ThomaStik-Infield (TI) Jazz flat, it’s just about the best Flats option out there, super expressive and long lasting. Here’s the sample between TI Jazz round and TI Jazz flats, polar opposite. The Jazz round is arguably the brightest set out there, I just love them. If I could afford it I’d put them on all my basses. :rofl:

All knobs are at 0 no boost no cut, that’s how I roll.

I hope this would help, I’m of course 100% bias, if judging by the amount of bass brand own, then I’m definitely a MusicMan Fanboi.

Let me know if you have any questions.

13 Likes

Like everyone else said - strings
But also, amp
You’re driving a Ferrari that you put a radio Shack stereo in to listen to music

The rumble 40 is fine for practice and beginners but a better amp will make the bass sing before you change the strings. Go bring it and try out all manner of amps and then decide if strings are blended to investigate

2 Likes

Thanks so much for the feedback. Glad to hear you are now enjoying your Sire Z3.

2 Likes

I really appreciate you taking the time to share such wonderful thoughts. I can’t thank you enough.

2 Likes

Much appreciated. I’ll get to Guitar Center early next week and try the bass with better amps.

2 Likes

Thanks for the thoughts!

2 Likes

I really appreciate it. Thank you.

2 Likes

Fantastic feedback. Many thanks.

2 Likes