C Am F G chord progression & pentatonic

Hello!
I am training to play simple bass line on basics chords progression.
I started with C | Am | F | G

I want also to use a pentatonic scale.
Because the song is in C, I take C major pentatonic:
https://www.guitarscale.org/bass/c-pentatonic-major.html

But I have a problem when I have to play the F chords because… F is not in the scale.

Is there something I misunderstood ?

Thanks!

2 Likes

Well, don’t let a rule (or scale) limit you to what you can play! Trust your ears!!

In any case, you should be good with ALL notes from the C major scale over ALL of these chords as they are all diatonic to C major.

So, yes, F may not be in the C major penta scale, but it’s in the C major scale.

You’re good :smile:

1 Like

As Wooten the Great once said: “It’s the wrong notes that makes things interesting”. The rules, much like the Pirate’s Code, are more like guidelines.

Even if you’re sticking to the pentatonic scale for the majority of it, a little chromatic action here and there as a walk up or flourish will take it from basic to…uhm…bwoah.

1 Like

Great question! That shape works over any major chord, so another option is to switch to F major pentatonic when you get to the F chord for a stronger sound. You can just slide the same shape up 5 frets. The 5 notes starting with F are also in the C major scale, so it all works.

1 Like

Thanks for the idea, I find it amazing that C, F and even G have the same notes in major pentatonic. It really is magic!

I’m not sure I totally agree. I don’t mind that rules can be twisted, distorted or ignored when you reach a certain level of mastery, but since I’m still in the learning phase, it doesn’t hurt to understand how “it works”.
I’m not the kind of genius who, like Picasso, knew how to draw perfectly at the age of 6 and then spent his life reinventing ways of painting.

One of the “rules” is to know the rules before you break them. It’s the same in photography, one of the rules is to not put the subject in the center of the frame and use things like the rule of thirds… But sometimes you want to emphasize symmetry and you do want to put the subject in the center.

Victor wooten says a lot of things to demonstrate concepts about music but they’re usually only true in certain contexts. “There are no wrong notes” is not always true in all cases, all the time, because there definitely are wrong notes… Even in Jazz :smile:

Van Gogh only started his art career at the age of 27 and only it only lasted for 10 years. He produced around 2100 works including almost 900 paintings. He spent the first several years developing his techniques and did most of his paintings in the last few years of his life. Not everyone is a prodigy :slightly_smiling_face:

Fully understood!
This is where scales and melodies and scales and bass players have to go to different sides of the room.

If you were a noodle-y guitar player playing solos or coming up with a melody, the simple approach to play something nice over that chord progression would be:
Play things that you think sound good using just the C major pentatonic scale.
It wouldn’t sound perfect all the time (you’d still miss the F, for example) but it would sound over all very good - as a melody - over those chords, and you’d avoid hitting really bad, sour notes.

But!
You’re a bassist.

So for us, we can’t drop something light and shimmery over the top of the structure that will be shiny and nice, but has no real connection to the structure of the song.
You have to start at the bottom - the foundation.

So your bass line has to start with root notes on each of those chords.

Once you know the root pattern and can keep it perfectly and have a nice groove going, if you’re looking for other notes to add, the other notes have to fit inside each chord you’re on.

Unlike the guitarist/melody maker (who can ignore the underlying structure a bit so long as their notes sound nice and connect to the melody and key), all of the bass notes have to connect to the structure, which is the chords.

So the notes you play during the “C” part of the playalong have to connect to C.
If you’re adding pentatonic scales to embellish the bass line, the scale has to align to the type of chord. So, if it’s a C major chord you’re playing to, the bass line should be based around the C root note, and you can add notes from the C major pentatonic.

For the next chord, your entire world shifts, because the foundation is building from a new sound: the A minor.
You have to move to the A root note. If you want to embellish the bass line with a pentatonic scale, you have to add the notes from A minor pentatonic - because that’s the sound that matches the chord.

When you move to F, you have to move the bass to the F root note.
If you want to embellish the bass line during the F chord, you should use the F major pentatonic scale.

Same for G (starting from a G root, and using the G major pentatonic scale).

Using that basic guideline will give you a good bass line, will use scales appropriately, and will - hopefully - explain why you can’t just play C major pentatonic the entire time as a bass player.

Lemme know if this helps!
This is such a common and confusing thing, and I have been on a quest to try and make this more understandable lately with my writing and students!!
Best of luck to you!

6 Likes

Thanks for your detailed answer.
I crystal clear now.

1 Like

Thank you for explaining this, @Gio . A big puzzle piece just clicked into place in my mind.

I had previously read that for improvising, you could use the pentatonic scale corresponding to the key you were in, and you used that over all the chords in the song. But this is the first I’ve heard that this is just for the “melody side of the room”.

I had never realized that the pentatonic scales built on all the scale degrees (except the diminished) were diatonic to the key. Assuming the pentatonic scale has the same major/minor quality as the corresponding diatonic chord of course.

This is kind of amazing!

1 Like

Hooray!

You made my heart happy with this! So glad it helped.