What is the most comfortable pick-up to rest your thumb on?
What to avoid?
5 Likes
Best I have found are the humbuckers on a Yamaha TRBX304, which have a special little thumb cutout.
Normal humbuckers are usually good too.
7 Likes
PB pickups are not ideal at all for this. but, well … I do with what I have … 
6 Likes
Reverse P’s seem even worse 
4 Likes
about the basses I have (which are probably not a good representation of the gear that 2020 bassists use) the two best ones for thumb position are the SBV with its JB-like but with rounded edges pickups, and the Grabber with its soapbar-sized single coil.
The two Precision are not very comfortable because of the screws, and the Ibanez Jetking is horrible with its sharp pickup rings.
But I think that modern basses with soapbars are probably the most comfortable option.
5 Likes
Yep, I would say the same. Screws can be rather annoying on P and MM-style pickups whereas J pickups tend to offer only a small surface to rest on.
Only downside on my Sandberg seems to be finding the right way to rest my thumb 
4 Likes
Can confirm, super clever design!
4 Likes
that’s really worse on P pickups because the width of the pickup is more narrow
I’m pretty much sure that what I said is not english-proof at all. 
5 Likes
It’s clear enough. 
Worst P-pickups are those that have those Lego-block like edges digging into your thumb 
3 Likes
Reverse P style are a pig of a thing to use unless your double jointed hence the addition of many thumb rests.
I used to think the same of the P bass and added a thumb rest but then I got my Mustang and Rickenbacker 
.
You can just get away with using the pickups as a rest but it’s rather like hanging off of a cliff edge by your fingertips.
If you want to add a thumb rest I highly recommend the no-mod ones. No extra screws and can be removed without leaving and lasting damage to your bass
4 Likes