I wouldn’t look at it as being wrong! Like I said, these all sound very much like a P-bass to me, because effectively they all are P pickups in roughly the same place.
Here’s the reveal in a spoiler block, I think this is a really illustrative set of example tones.
Bass #1: Fender Japan Hybrid II Precision Bass, DiMarzio Model P, tone 100%
Bass #2: Yamaha BB734A, YGD v7 P pickup 100%, Passive, tone 100%
Bass #3: Yamaha BB734A, YGD v7 P pickup 100%, Active EQ flat
Bass #4: Warwick Rockbass Streamer LX4, MEC P pickup 100%, Active EQ flat
Interesting exercise 