I thought I was a cool looking awesome technique bass player until I saw some pics - left thumb over the top of the neck, fingers in a slant, one finger plucking etc
I had an idea my technique looked like John Deacon
But no.
I’ve told myself that my old wrist injury makes it uncomfortable to drop the wrist so I can get fingers parallel to the fret wires (it just doesn’t feel nice when playing frets 1-7 - I need to twist my wrist to reach or it feels like I’m forcing my shoulder and wrist into a painful place)
Thumb over the top? Well, sometimes it helps to mute the low B
The thing is - if I can play the notes ok, where’s the harm eh?
None of no injury over time. Experiment with bass height and pushing it out from your body at about a 45 degree angle where it belongs and see how your hand does.
My thumb likes the E string too. No worries there.
I tend to play with my thumb just over the top as well. I just started private lessons this week, asking to start to fix technique issues. This was the first thing my instructor pointed out as a need to fix. She said trying to play ofpf this way is a quick road to carpal tunnel. Part of my homework till next lesson is to pretend like I’ve got a penny in the palm of my fretting hand, the idea is to keep the palm flat and pointing up. Microshifting as needed.
Some interesting ideas thanks! I already push forward 45 degrees or else I end up smashing into the singers mic stand! (Curse these long necks)
I’ve not heard of the “hold a penny” idea. Does that suggest the neck of the bass is expected to be parallel to the floor? I tend to play quite “neck up” as my wrist really doesn’t like the neck level position. I’ve had to hoist my bass up as high as it can go on my strap. The neck where it meets the body is higher than my belly button. Maybe I should go a bit more “mark king”…. The longer the strap the harder It is for my left hand
All guitarists play this way so I’m not sure his statement is correct. That and carpal tunnel is a repetitive motion issue not a position issue. I had carpal tunnel surgery in both hands years from programming. Repetitive motion.
I’m sure you look cool! Most of the coolest players have terrible posture.
Thumb over the top is OK sometimes to helps with bends, but bad for most evertthing else. One thing that really helps is keeping the headstock high - like early Bill Wyman. I’m sure I’m rambling off topic.
I tend to be of the view that you can fret any way so long as it works and doesn’t cause discomfort or pain. I’m not hugely rigid; sometimes I have my thumb in the middle of the neck pointing at the head and all that good stuff, other times my thumb pokes up above the top of the neck. One works better for some bits and the other for others.
Recently @BeerBaron posted this video of Leland Sklar and I noticed that his thumb moves around a fair bit, frequently making an appearance over the top of the neck, and does a lot of micro (or not so micro) shifting. He rarely spreads his fretting fingers out in any long reaches but rather shifts his hand instead.
I guess he’s not a bad model to emulate!
ETA: I think it’s also not a bad thing to let your wrist move into different positions. Even if one particular position is best for avoiding carpal issues, if you hold that position rigidly all the time no matter what, I’d guess you’re probably heading towards such problems anyway. Relax, use the hand position that works best for each riff and avoid death grips with that hand and you should be fine.
Leland seems to telegraph his next sound with his hand, like a natural Air Bender. I notice when he wants the flow to go a certain way he’d cup his hand, which in turns produces great flows through the phrase. This happens a lot on the recording with Lari Basilio and of course his play along channel, which I’d watch almost daily. Very chatty fella too, I probably talk to him for 15 minutes at an Apple Store in Pasadena while waiting for the Genius Bar.
I just posted this video on another thread, I summoned my inner Leland Sklar every time I play one of his song. It’s very powerful especially on this song as I’ve never touch a bass while learning it until I sat down and hit record. This is first and only take, Thanks Leland.
Even Geddy does the baseball bat grip sometimes. Just pay the way that is most comfortable.
I had a stroke 4-years ago, and the middle fingers on my left hand, though not useless, will never regain the dexterity they once had, so I had to modify how I played.
I tried going lefty. but that was just too foreign, so I settled on more strings, as I work better across the neck than up an down these days.
Multiscale (Fanned Fret) basses also helped me A LOT. You may want to test drive one at your local gear spot.
Anyway, don’t worry about the “poor-form” snobs; just play how it feels best to you.