Frustrated with fingering index to pinkie

Hi all,

I’m in M7, trying to do the ‘In the Midnight Hour’ slow workout; thus far, I’ve sucked at it, and I’m not even keeping up to speed on the slow workout. When I do play it at speed, there are so many bwangs and scrapes that it sounds like ass. I mean, I know it’s index to pinkie to middle, but I can’t do it fast enough, and I’m a bit embarrassed.

If nothing else, I’ve found inner peace, since I’ve accepted that my account may be deactivated due to my shitty bass playing. I’m guessing they will also note my account on the BassBuzz Hall of Shame, a horror story for generations to come. Okay, well, maybe it won’t be that bad, yet I am unsure of a “hack” to better fret E4-E7-E5 smoother (besides practice).

3 Likes

Slow it down, even from the slow workout. There’s also nothing that says you can’t move forward and come back to it later.

3 Likes

Nah, dude. You’re good. Don’t sweat not nailing it first take. It’s boring advice but practice makes for progress. As long as you’re putting in time on bass you’re gonna get better. It takes time to get your fingers to go where you want them to go. Keep working the index to pinky to middle and it will keep sounding better. You can try micro shifting so you don’t have to stretch your fingers so much. The more you go from index on the 4th fret to pinky on the 7th and middle on the 5th the smoother it’ll get. Keep at it and keep it fun and you’ll keep getting better.

4 Likes

Thanks, Rob and Jacob! :slightly_smiling_face:
I’ve been practicing since I posted and I can already see some progress!
Ok then, I’ve slowed it down, and it’s sounding cleaner already. My biggest struggle now is pinkie strength. I think when I push it down, it can pull the string and cause a ‘bwang’.
Also, I have focused on first putting my index and pinkie fingers on the frets, instead of doing the four fingers in order.
Ah ha! Just now I practiced lifting my finger off the fret faster after plucking…I think that should help lessen the side noises…?

2 Likes

Go slow. Play with clean technique. Rinse and repeat. Many, many times over.

This is the way.

If you do this, you will eventually and naturally build up your speed.

Patience and practice pay off. You just have to work the plan.

You got this. :+1:

5 Likes

First - try to memorize the sound of the phrase, while you play it slow. It will be way easier to recreate that sound while playing fast.

Second - maybe try to use another fingering, more comfortable to you. For example I play more of a Simandle technique so just shifted my hand to reach 4 fret with my index and 7 fret with my pinky (and played 5 fret also with index - because after shifting to 7 my index lands perfectly on 5 fret)

P.S. Sheet music rules - because there we can see that we deal with two major chords: E major and A major in the key of E. And those chords are root (I) and fifth (V) of the E scale - with that you can figure out how to play this phrase with ease.

2 Likes

The other comments are all valid, especially going slower. It’s not that big a stretch but if it’s getting your fingers tangled you could try alternative fingering like this:

Personally when I played it I used the 0-4-7-5 fingering but this alternative is the same notes. However it is good to get comfortable with moving farther up the neck.

2 Likes

Thanks, Mike :slight_smile: .
I practiced last night and saw that it is possible for me to do the fret fingering at a fast speed (albeit not cleanly, lol).
Good point…take it slow and focus on good form and technique, not on “passing the module level, to get to the next one”.
Thanks again, bro.

1 Like

Thanks, Alex, I’ll try that, too.
I think the Simandl technique is worth trying out.

Fair point about sheet music…Josh taught all of it in Module 7, but it was somewhat “Greek” to me. But, I will watch the lessons again to better understand the major chords. Going off memory, I recall the fretting is something like, for example, going from the 3rd to 5th fret, then switching strings and playing three frets, then playing three frets on the third string, although not in the exact same order as the previous string. But, damn it, I’ll get this to ‘click’ and shall overcome :slight_smile: :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

Thanks, bro!
I’ll check it out. :slight_smile:

1 Like