I have the same motivations for recording covers. Additionally it’s nice to have set challenges which can be finished when learning something, recording covers of songs fills that purpose for me.
‘Small timing issues’ is the big issue for me at the moment though. Often I can play a song all the way through but there’ll be a bar or two where I drift a bit during it. Being 100% locked in for 4-5 minutes feels like a big challenge!
What do you mean by “punch in and fix” mistakes, like re-record them? If you make only a few mistakes in a take is it good enough for you to move on at that point and post your cover?
I listen to the song first. Then I find the notation, whatever that is. Once I get the jist of what the bassline is, Ill play it until I get it. I think your 90 percent rule is great. I should keep that in mind myself. As long as you’re still having fun, thats all that matters.
Yeah find the “missed” section and replay just that section correctly. It’s a common practice in the recording (audio) a bit different when you do video unless of course you are doing similar editing like me.
This is more of a personal satisfaction, it takes time to “feel” the music and flow through it. The issue is not “more” attention needed but the opposite. You need to master the art of paying less attention. If you are counting (consciously) in the middle of the song, worse thinking about your form, you are in trouble. I once made a comment to a guest bass player that he played with such great form and alternating the fingers masterfully, he F-ed up so bad on the next song,
Take songs like Twist and Shout, or Venus, both have relatively fast, repeating phrases (ostinato). If I think about what I’m doing, I inevitably fall over myself.
That’s interesting!
I am arguably the worst bass player EVER, due to utter lack of talent. It took some time for me to admit it this, but now I feel a certain freedom in my mediocrity..
Still, I really enjoy playing bass (as a challenge or as a “meditation”), and I “play” a lot of covers.
But since I have started creating my own songs, I “abuse” playing covers for warming up, understanding the parts that I like … and improvise variations of those bass lines to get inspired to do my own stuff.
Often, it’s just filling the blanks, especially when the original bass line is very reduced or it can be played differently. Or I make mistakes that sound interesting.
Mistakes are really great now!
This way I often create a new melody which reflects the mood of the original, but is different otherwise … and I just use the beat of the original covered song to further my own exploration into something new.
Since I decided to not pursue perfection in covers, my life became much better
Pretty perfect, which my beginner talent probably wouldn’t suggest, haha. Not including practice time to learn the track, recording seems to take a good few hours depending on how many takes I blow. I want them to be good enough to watch and hear without any obviously amateurish mixing/visual problems, but like the instrument itself, it’s all a work in progress, and there’s definitely an upper limit where your time is just better spent practicing off-camera.
So much this. Once you know the line, just play it without concentrating too hard on it. When you start to concentrate, you tense up and start making mistakes. That’s part of why when there’s a part that you struggle with, if you play it right once, you start messing it up if you try it again right after. You’re paying “too much” attention to try to recreate what you did the prior time.
Relaxation is the key, but at the same time if you’re telling yourself to relax then you get less relaxed.
I have a general rule for myself that I won’t do more than two or three full playthroughs of the song when recording. If I don’t get a take that I’m happy with in that time then I just stop and try again another day. I find that the more times I stop and re-start the more I tense up, which in turn means I’m more likely to mess up more and more.
That’s a great rule, actually, I think I’ll try that. I always do a couple ‘off the record’ playthroughs first and if I’m nailing them, on with the camera we go. But ‘red light syndrome’ or whatever they call it seems to be very real!
Yeah Good luck with that,
Not gonna lie, when the camera is on it’s tough. I usually play without looking at the fingerboard so I look around in the crowds then when I scan my eyes and see a camera with the Red light on! well, you know the rest,
I always record my audio and video in separate takes. I get way more nervous with the camera on. Way more likely to make mistakes. If you’ve ever watched my cover videos, there’s almost always some mistakes on the video side. It adds some extra steps in post production getting everything synced up but it’s worth it to me to be able to relax and just play while I’m laying down the audio.