Learning process and it's building

Maybe something similar was already discussed, but - how to properly build your learning process and schedule timewise both to to avoid hurrying up and maintaining progress?

Like I have now

  1. Excercises on open strings from Simandl book - to work on my plucking technique. I just did all of them on 60 bpm, but want to gradually increase plucking speed but without worthening the tone (like even work of both fingers, not missing fingers and so on)

  2. Fretting excercises also from Simandl book - position by position also with gradually increasing speed.

  3. Rich Brown’s Brown’Stone lessons

  4. Continue B2B

  5. Bonus - Maybe adding some Hal Leonard/Jeff Berlin or other stuff (not necessarily)

How to better arrange my learning schedule to include this all while not hurrying things up and making progress? I can practice for now something like 1 hour per day (After straining my right wrist because of playing too much don’t want hurt myself again - so 1 hour per day seems perfect for now).

2 Likes

You’d need to balance play and practice.
in the nutshell you’ll need to develop your finger strength
right hand development, you need to get your plugging hand down first
finger coordination
fret board knowledge
That should be as part of your warm up. may be 10-15 mins
If you want to put in your 15 mins lesson then do it here after warm up.

Then play, get your song list and notation or tabs then start cracking those, I’d spend at least 30 playing. That’s your 1 hour session right there.

I have a few songs that I put as part of my warmup and I rotate them, then start working on my “working songs” usually 3-5 songs, then play my current setlist before wrap. If I have no time and just want to blow 20 mins I just play sometimes random songs on my list.

We are so primitive and older, a 10 year old can pick these up in no time but for older folks this can take weeks or months simply because we got other things to do and life gets in the way. Got stuck on an island with bass and amp and internet, you’ll be just as fast as 10 year old. :joy:

5 Likes

My $0.02

  1. Focus on B2B
  2. put Simandl and other books aside
  3. Start learning a very simple song all the way through (look at 50 song challenge)
  4. Rich Brown is a fantastic option when you want different from B2B

I think you are over thinking this quite a bit and certainly splitting your practice time up way too much. In a couple decades of sax practice it has always been the same, do 3-things, focus on them.

For sax it is:

1. long tones (warmup)

2. technique exercises - main focus

3. song or two

Bass requires less warmup than sax, even none quite frankly, but if you do want it - run a scale or two to learn them as well.

4 Likes

I dunno, If i need a warm-up - just don’t want to hurt myself again (pain in the wrist sucks…)

If I can chime in here, I would put all this other stuff away. Put on a slow song that has an easy bass line and see if you can play it. Nothing taught me how to play more than playing. Josh gave me the fundamentals and it was up to ,e to build on those.

How did you learn to ride a bike? Not by reading books about it, you rode.

3 Likes

Over-doing it and too much computer keyboard/mouse and phone use is more often the culprit than warming up. Warming up is really no different than playing or doing a lesson.

This was going to be my comment. You’re massively over-thinking this and trying to do too much.

  • Focus only on B2B until complete - no external practice
  • Bias towards more frequent, short B2B sessions. No more than 30 minutes at a time, 1 to 3 a day. Give yourself 5 minutes to warm up with light hand stretches.
  • Stick with the techniques Josh is showing during the course. Simandl can come later when you really need it (I prefer it too).
  • slow down and focus more. Choose focus over trying to go fast
  • get plenty of rest between lessons.

You will learn much more effectively this way.

5 Likes

But what if Josh’s fingerings are not comfortable for me, for example?

That’s expected. You will be growing in your ability to stretch over the course of the course, and also in microshifting.

Yes, that’s what I practice while doing Rich Brown’s lessons (mostly in 1-2-4 style (Simandle) with small microshifting sometimes but somewhere towards higher frets - 1-2-3 or OFPF depending of the fingering)

The other issue is - Josh suggests moving the plucking hand thumb to the string right above the one you pluck next. Rich on the other way do not insist on particular position - just find whatever works best for you (Rich himself never moves his thumb in other places, than pick or E string). For me now most comfortable is keeping the thumb either on the pick or on the E string (just need to work on moving the thumb smoother between the positions and not affecting plucking). So what?

1 Like

Each and every advice you find online or elsewhere should always be up for your own review. Fingerings are suggestions and, yes, you should certainly explore different ones, especially if you have “medical”/anatomical reasons to try/prefer different fingerings.

That all said: you also need to trust a teacher to a) have thought about the suggested fingerings and b) have a certain learning goal in mind.

Give the suggested fingering a try; if it doesn’t work for you (or if you have discomfort or pain), adjust them to your needs. (That is what I do, having to cope with a slight condition with my fretting hand pinky, but I also wouldn’t consider myself a real beginner anymore, i.e., I have accrued some knowledge and experience that lets me make such decisions more easily).

1 Like

Moving the thumb gives the advantage of natural and free muting. I would recommend learning that.

2 Likes

I would consider you actually accomplished at this point :rofl:

I agree with everything Jörg said.

1 Like

Thanks, Howard. But, still, I am not a teacher (of bass, at least) :wink:

1 Like

Yep, same. Why I usually advise to defer to the teacher :slight_smile:

1 Like

We might have been around the block a few times, but not all our advice is necessarily part of a larger educational framework and an integral part of such.
(“legal disclaimer” :rofl: )

1 Like

Yeah lol. I am more a cautionary tale than anything.

2 Likes

The question is - how much time from a daily practice session to dedicate to particular area? Like how much time to work on

  • Timing/rhythm/groove
  • Theory/harmony (scales, pentatonics, modes, chords etc.)
  • Technique
  • Ear training/Sight-reading
  • Songs/standards/riffs/licks analyzing and learning
  • Etc

Not to make it all counter-productive.

In other words - where is that time boundary or threshold, after reaching which it is the best to stop doing something until tomorrow, because there will be no progress today, and switch to another area?