@howard Actually, standing up it feels much better, than when I am sitting.
4 Likes
I bet. I think your problem is much more of simple positioning of the bass there when sitting than anything you are doing.
I personally don’t like playing sitting for this reason, the bass is in a different spot than when standing for me. Just feels kinda wrong.
4 Likes
There are all sorts of body movements and adjustments that I have to make to get to different areas.
The best way I’ve found for working through these shifts is with set exercises that make me move from 1st fret all the way up my fretboard and back again.
I like to do exercises that don’t involve any scales or brain power to remember, so that I can focus only on fingering technique and position shifting.
I do one I call the Spider Climb.
I start on the first fret of the E string and play frets 1-2-3-4
Then, A string: 2-3-4-5, then D: 3-4-5-6, then G: 4-5-6-7 once I’ve hit the G string, I bounce back towards the E string, always moving up one fret at a time - so -
after G: 4-5-6-7, it’s D string: 5-6-7-8 and so on and so on.
I usually stop when I get to the 13th fret of the G string, then go back.
G: 13-12-11-10, D: 12-11-10-9, and reverse the excercise.
If you can shift through all the positions on the way up, you’ll get an idea of what your arms and body need to do to accommodate the access to the upper register.
Lemme know if it helps.
9 Likes
Thanks @Gio I’m going to do it tonight. Watching that video I was thinking there’s got to be a transition-- but how does she do it? Answer: we’re all made differently, but do the Spider Climb and work it out! It’s just going to take effort, that’s why I hit the brakes in module 7 thinking, “Quit pretending! You need to figure this out, else you’re going to limp through these lessons as they get harder.” So, I did spend nearly an hour analyzing everything I do, taking pics, etc. I’m sure the Spider Climb is going to help me work out the last kinks. I"ve gotten a lot better already since starting this thread. 
4 Likes
i would say try your bass in classical guitar position
if play sitting this is my preferred position as well, it opens up the fretboard.
and practise, practise makes perfect and it will take time… long time
3 Likes
So I described my problem in the small hands thread ( Small hands need help! - #44 by juli0r ) including video, but now that I see
(Developing Safe Left Hand Technique for Bass Guitar)
And the takeaway I get from that is: I worried about the thumb too much. When letting go with it I can easily wrap my hand around and reach the 17th fret with the pinky. Hope I got that right.
7 Likes
It does. I spent 15 minutes with it and then 5 or 6 minutes with the major scale. It’s a good exercise not only for the reason stated, but it also gives me the opportunity to work on fretting clean notes as well! I’m going to use this as a warm up before Josh’s lessons going forward.
4 Likes
I have to agree that neck has to be up, else it’s misery, and there’s a good point about leaning. I agravated an old back injury last week (right side lumbar), and I think I may have been leaning into it too much and too long.
I haven’t decided what I’ll end up with yet; I need to work through it. I think in the end, I have to accept that people are built differently, and as much as I want to hold the bass like Josh (after all you want to imitate your teacher), you have to with what works. I’m a stocky 6’2" in that I have short legs for a man my height ( 30" pant length), so I have a long middle. I have to work with that, so I study other accomplished bass players with similar builds to see what they are doing. Ben Burleigh is a great example, but he’s holds it differently in many cases, and I think that goes back to what Gio was getting at earlier.
Thanks for the video!
2 Likes
Hooray!
… of everything having to do with killer bass playing. He’s a hero of mine in these parts as well. You can find him on Facebook too - he’s been posting remote-recorded videos recently, and his playing is dynomite. Also a good example to see him in different positions, postures, and playing all over the neck.
6 Likes
I really liked his input in the gear reviews you guys did. Both of you helped influence my decision a lot.
3 Likes
Thanks @Gio for that excercises. I have been looking for, and finding some quality excercises to help with positioning, strength and dexterity. I am adding this to what I have going now.
Do you have any other suggested excercises you do, or recommend?
Maybe a thread dedicated to this. Sharing the excercises, and explaining what they are, and what they are helping to achieve?
3 Likes
I did too. Most of all I was happy that Josh, Gio and Ben gave some love to the entry level basses. It’s ok to run with a Squier; I’ve been very happy with mine after I upgraded the electronics ( Fender pots, Switchcraft jack – which was broken) and Seymour Duncan pickups. The only thing that will take that bass out of my hands is Fender with a smoother satin neck!
2 Likes
Good to know; I didn’t find much of him on YouTube except as an accompanist in a band. I’ll look for him!
3 Likes
I like this idea! Though, if I know Josh and BassBuzz, this will most likely already be in the pipeline for a super killer video soon to blow minds and change the world. Whaddaya think @JoshFossgreen?
5 Likes
Hells yeah!, I know it will change my world.
If there is a video with an introduction thread, that will be a good place to add on with other exercises, from anyone who has one.
4 Likes
Haha, flattery will get you everywhere. 
Yeah, I really want to cover basic playing positioning / technique stuff like this in more, better detail in the future. I think there are a lot of gaps in how it’s normally taught (including myself in that assessment). There are so many things to figure out! It would be easier if we all had the exact same body shape, then teachers could give exact recommendations and they would actually work!
9 Likes
Every little bit helps! There’s a lot of stuff on your old channel, and I cull that and look for clues. As I gain experience, I see things I’ve never seen before, and for others, I just need to practice consistently and wait for things to develop.
None of this would have been possible for me without your course. No time for a 1 on 1 teacher, and your encouragement is priceless. Thanks for showing me what could be possible.
4 Likes
I would love a video like that!
In fact the only teaching video (playalongs excluded) I liked apart from your course and youtube videos was the video of the guy explaining hand positioning.
I always struggle between:
“That’s easy - that’s the way I’ll do it.”
“Am I actively learning a bad habit here?”
And since flattery will get me everywhere: Your course videos are the single best instruction videos I’ve ever seen. And I’m not narrowing it down to music. I’m talking instruction video. I have never seen any better. I don’t know how you do it, but even if I repeat a video 20 times in a row your comments do not annoy me.
One would expect to get a little bit frustrated and take it out on the screen as one often does in video games after failing a boss fight too many times and not being able to skip the cutscene. But no… impossible for me to be mad at you.
Sure it’s flattery and I might have an ulterior motive, but I’m not lying just to flatter you. I mean it.
5 Likes
I’d like to add also it’s good to have @Gio here when Josh is away. Gio has given tons go great advice ( in great detail) and encouragement to us rank beginners. It means a lot, because we’re just trying to get going. He never talks down to us, though he’s well beyond us.
5 Likes
I absolutely agree. I value @Gio very much in this community.
I just was stuck in the thought of motivating Josh and/or the bassbuzz team.
5 Likes