Pinky tendon severed!

About 30 years ago, when I was a teenger, I had an accident that involved severing the tendon to my pinky finger. I suspect this was a big part of me, perhaps subconciously, deciding not to pursue bass back then when I had the chance.

The smaller circle in the pic shows where the initial accident cut the tendon. The larger circle shows where the surgeon cut down my wrist, looking for the other end that had shot up my forearm. He never found it, and the pinky tendon was spliced onto that of my ring finger.

I am a lefty, so the pic is of my fretting hand.

At the time the doctors told me I would lose about 15% of function in extension. Flexion is not affected. It does have the weird effect that if I lift off with my pinky finger, I also HAVE to lift off with my ring finger. That’s just how my fingers work now.

I’ve now been playing for about a year (I started at the same time as my 10-year old son, whom we started buying lessons for - he plays an Ibanez Mikro :smiley: ). I have been slowly progressing through the course and I’ve just finished the Major Scale module.

I can play basic tunes and jam along to Yousician or with school students, whom I play with at lunchtimes - I’m a High School teacher. However, I’ve noticed I get a lot of resonance sometimes where my right hand muting isn’t so great when I’m fretting different notes, like in string crossing. I find my fingers tend to ‘hop off’ one set of strings and onto the next, instead of staying planted and fingers acting independantly.

The Major Scales module has got me thinking a lot more about fretting, and I’ve noticed great bassists keep ALL their fingers down on the string as they lift off or fret different notes throughout the scale. This is very, very tough for me. I tend to ‘SeeSaw’ a lot as SBL puts it, lifting off fingers when I actually want to keep them planted. This is expecially true of my index and middle fingers when I’m looking to fret with my pinky.

I also find the ‘four finger stretch’, playing one finger per fret very difficult, even though I’m very tall with large hands - my fingers just don’t seem to want to stay disciplined and orderly and stay planted while I stretch out my pinky.

I do get some pain/discomfort across the back of my hand when playing scales in a very strict and controlled way, although I do find I can work through this a lot of the time without too much difficulty.

Am I doomed?! :smiley: I did watch Josh’s video on the Simandl technique and wonder whether this is worth pushing into more? I’m not discouraged, and am really enjoying the course, and playing, and making small wins. However, I wonder if there is a better way for me to adapt my playing.

Thanks all!

8 Likes

I was thinking about dinner when you posted and thought it said ‘Pink Tenderloin Served’.

Well, you’ll never play like John Entwistle with your disability, but most people won’t either, so nothing to lose sleep over.

If it were me and it was causing pain, I might try leaving it out of the mix, at least temporarily. Josh is a leftie, but plays bass right handed, so maybe that could be an option too.

4 Likes

This was going to be my response.

5 Likes

Oddly, my left hand seems to learn delicate tasks more quicky than my right hand, however, driving a manual transmission in England, my left hand never really got quick. Maybe I had to concentrate too much on staying in the proper lane.

3 Likes

Thank you very much. Its a really good suggestion. A year ago, when I was looking for a bass, I did consider trying a right-hander. However, I’ve always thought of myself as very ‘one-sided’ and not at all ambidextrous. Trying to play right-handed feels very alien…

As it was, a cheap Cort Action Plus in lefty cropped up locally, and I bought that and haven’t looked back. I’ve since upgraded to a Squier CV Jazz in lefty… I guess I could start again, but in spite of the restriction, I don’t yet feel like my progress is ‘capped’ by it, if that makes sense. Yes, its there, but I feel like I could carry on making progress without it being a massive impediment.

But yeah, maybe I’ll practise more with my son’s bass, which is a righty, and try and figure it out.

4 Likes

I basically only play Simandl. You’ll be fine. This won’t stop you.

6 Likes

Maybe you’ll just leave your pinkie out of the mix, who knows.

James Jamerson only plucked with his index finger and he went pretty far.

Regardless, I really think that DMSO works wonders for fatigued joints and tendons. I use it all the time.

4 Likes

Thank you for the encouragement, I appreciate it!

4 Likes

Yeah also for your plucking hand it won’t be much of an issue at all.

2 Likes

This is my plucking hand. The scar extends up around my thumb actually. Whacked the nerve in two that controls the index and middle finger and thumb. I could move those fingers, but couldn’t feel them. This was in 2019. Doesn’t look like much now, but at the time I didn’t think I was gonna make it him. Called my Mom on the way to the ER because I legit thought I was bleeding out and just wanted to talk to her one last time.

Always wanted to learn guitar but never made the effort. After the above scenario I started taking our limited time on Earth more seriously. Couldn’t feel my fingers, so didn’t expect much. I couldn’t feel shit for about 3 years. Started teaching myself bass and started having strange/painful pins & needles type sensations in the affected area. Whatever, that’s just life with nerve damage. Over then next two years (ish) I’ve been playing bass every day, forcing that hand to do fine motor stuff, and it started healing. It’s 95% back to normal now. Only weirdness left is it hurts trim cut my fingernails, but I think that’s some neurotic thing in my own mind. Rambling, but the point is: Don’t worry about. Things unused will atrophy, but if you go ahead and use them you just might be surprised what you can rehab just simply by using it. The hand specialist that put me back together says it not possible. Oh well :slightly_smiling_face:

6 Likes

Kudos dude. Inspiring story, thank you for sharing. My difficulties pale into insignificance!

I guess we adapt and find a way.

3 Likes

I broke my ring finger earlier in life (on what would become my fretting hand) and did not get it reset properly, so now when I bend my fingers my ring and pinky fingertips close to the same place…this makes using both separately for fretting impossible, so I only ever use the first three fingers…

it takes some adjustment to instructions given in bass buzz lessons etc. and more micro shifting but I don’t think it is a big deal compared with what some other people deal with

I am also lefty and would never switch to righty as the plucking hand is where the rhythm lives so I want that to be my dominant hand

here is me playing a cover I just posted where you can see my three finger fretting (with poor old pinky just along for the ride)

6 Likes

Thank you, its great to know there are other people out there that have overcome similar challenges!

5 Likes

No!

But… you probably will not be able to do everything, and at least not everything “by the book”.

I have a pinky situation on my fretting hand also (somewhat different from yours). I have to accept that, and adapt to this situation. Like Howard, I only use Simandl (and micro-shifting). From fret 0 to ca. fret 10, I use index-middle-pinky, above fret 10, I use index-middle-ring (mostly; some exceptions).

I guess, you just have to make it work and accept some limitations. For example, if I want to fret on the D string, my pinky is not “curved” enough, such that I often also touch the G string in the process. I am aware of this, and try to adjust my fretting to minimize this as much as possible, but I probably can’t avoid it entirely.

What does this mean? Well, in live situations, it doesn’t really matter. For recordings, you can hear that I touch and slightly press on the G string - it’s audible when isolating the bass track. In the mix, it isn’t really that audible anymore, and I will have to live with never having “perfect” recordings.

Lots of people find their style of playing while having to deal with various smaller and larger handicaps. I am sure you can make it work as well :smiley:

7 Likes

This is great advice thank you. I’ll think about splitting up the fretboard and try to find what’s comfortable. Its great to know that people much further on in their journey have found ways to get round their difficulties - I haven’t thought of recording myself yet! :smiley:

3 Likes

I don’t have anything like your problems, but I have got arthritis in my fretting pinky. If I try to use anything more than an occassional fret it gets seriously painful.

It’s really not that hard to leave the pinky out and just do a little more micro shifting. Works for me!

3 Likes

I also injured my left ring finger but in my case it was a knife slip that severed a nerve. The tip and second segment of my left ring finger is basically like Shinyribs’ thumb and just pins and needles and hurts to trim the nail. Makes fretting that 2nd (and others) note in Billie Jean more difficult as I can’t really feel it or control it well.

4 Likes

I relate. Played guitar for 50 years. I snapped two tendons on fretting hand playing racquetball about 6 years ago. Had a double tendon transfer (sounds like that was what you had on the pinky). Guitar playing days over. But almost 2 years ago at age 70 said to myself maybe a 4 string bass would be doable. I am having a gas and it is the best PT. I can’t stretch like I used to, but adapting well and can use my pinky okay. I won’t ever be Jaco, but my skills are getting better. Downside is BAS (GAS) hit me. Started with some shortscales but now also alternate between a Fullerton SB-2 and Fender Am Pro 2 Jazz. I gotta tell you: Bass is way more fun than guitar! Hang in and adapt!

3 Likes

I can relate to this somewhat too.

Not the same as a severed tendon, but I have cubital tunnel syndrome, which is kind of the elbow version of carpal tunnel, because of the way I rested my arms on my desk to type for 20 years as a database guy.

The end result is that on my fretting hand, my pinky and ring finger are in varying degrees of pain and tingling at any given time. I thought about going lefty because of it and just committing to that, but then I realized how it limited my options in terms of gear with left-handed basses, so I decided to bite the bullet and go for it regular style.

I’m using a couple hand exerciser thingies to try and increase the strength in my pinky especially, cuz sometimes I can’t even feel what it’s doing really, and I need it to be strong. Of course practice will also do that but this is something I can do when I’m laying in bed or I’m not in a position to be playing bass lol.

2 Likes

I love how this thread has turned into ‘Finger injury survivors club’, its so good to know there are others out there just adapting and getting on with things. Some of the stories make my difficulties pale into insignificance.

I know some people say that going lefty would limit thier options in terms of basses. I feel like unless you want something really expensive or exotic, there is something out there for you. I started on a Cort Action Plus, then after about six months got my Squier CV Jazz. If I ever want to upgrade (which I might soon!) then, even in Australia, I feel like I could choose from a Fender, Schecter, Warwick, or a Stingray.

Besides, I don’t think my wife will let me own more than two at a time anayway…

2 Likes