The anchored thumb and string crossing down strings with the plucking hand

Hello, I’m Joe from the UK. I had a handful of bass lessons at school many years ago, since then I’ve played the bass here and there, watching youtube lessons randomly and learning songs without every laying down good foundations (until recently starting the BtB course which is awesome!).

I have two technique questions regarding habits I have formed with the plucking hand. Correcting these bad habits will be tricky as they are engrained, so I want to know if it is worthwhile correcting them a it will certainly require going backstepping.

Habit 1 - relocating the anchored thumb: I either rest my thumb of the plucking hand on the E string (if playing strings A, D or G) or on the body of the bass to the side of the pickup and just slighty above the E string (when playing the E string). How important is it that I learn to rest the thumb on the A string also? I know there are some proposed muting benefits but I find transitioning the anchored thumb from the A to E (or vice versa) very tricky and end up creating unwanted noise during the transition as the thumb leaves the string it was resting on. This is impossible for me when plying Billie Jean at full speed and I know it will require lots of effort. I feel pretty comfy with resting my thumb on E or having it float on the body.

Habit 2: this i regarding a habit of not alternate plucking when crossing strings, but only when moving to a lower consecutive string. For example, if I play the G string with my first finger and then the next note is on the D string, I will always play that note with the first finger instead of alternating to the 2nd finger. This is because the first finger comes naturally to rest on the D after playing the G, so it seems more efficient to use it again as it almost just rolles over the strings and its there ready to strike the string above. I can swap over to the 2nd finger, but the moment I play anything fast or more complex its very tricky to unlearn.

I hope my tired brain has explained this well! Thanks :smiley:

1 Like

Regarding this one, the question is asked in the comments section of lots of the lesson videos. Long story short, what you’re doing–called “raking”–isn’t wrong. Josh doesn’t specifically teach it mainly because he wants to make sure people get good at alternating plucking and make sure both plucking fingers develop skill/strength. That said, if you were up on stage and did some raking, no one is going to jump up on stage and berate you for doing it wrong. Nobody will even notice.

1 Like

Thanks Vader, I’ll rake away. And use the search feature more thoroughly when I next have a question

1 Like

Better to get in the bag it of floating that thumb for muting - it will bite you as you progress and give unwanted noise. You will get used to it in time. Dont force it, it will start to come naturally. I tend to anchor A but still touch E with the back part of my thumb to mute both salt the same time. Don’t leave E hanging or it will complain and you will hear it.

2 Likes