Yamaha TRBX304 vs. Squier Classic Vibe 70's P Bass

So I have just sold the SX bass I’ve had for the last couple of years to help fund a new one. The SX was absolutely fab for its price but I’ve been feeling the GAS for a while now and just wanted to feel the experience of playing a different bass. Unfortunately can’t afford atm to have two, so I sold it.

I’m really torn between two models that are sort of in my price range. I love the versatility of the TRBX304, it seems like a lot of fun to play with the different tones. However I also really love the sound of the CV 70s p bass, and in terms of design I find it more attractive.

I know it’s kind of pointless to ask which I should get but I thought it would be nice to share as I’ve been driving myself mental with deciding :laughing: What do y’all think?

4 Likes

Both are excellent beginner basses and are very different. There isn’t a wrong choice between those two.

So get both :slight_smile:

I have owned that (and higher end) TRBX and thewhole line is great. I almost bought the Squier too much later but wentwith a Fender instead.

The Yamaha’s pickups are quite a bit better.

10 Likes

Yep, two different animals. Choose both or the one you like better. I have a trbx504 and the squier 70s CV Pbass. Both equally loved

5 Likes

So funny I just posted on another thread a few seconds ago. This is what a TRBX 305 sounds like in the studio.

4 Likes

When choosing between a pbass and anything else, the answer is always the pbass :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

2 Likes

I definitely feel like I’m leaning in that direction, there’s just something about its sound and design that calls to me

1 Like

With those two you are really unlikely to have regrets either way

1 Like

As my bass tutor told me, when it comes to buying a bass don’t listen to anyone else. Not your wife, mother, priest or social worker. Test drive as many as you need and buy the one that works for you; it’s your money and you have to live with it.

I take your point on budget, but have you thought about buying both second hand?

Finally, don’t ever, ever ask @Howard to help you choose between two basses as you’ll end up buying three.

12 Likes

I mean, in addition to both of those being excellent choices, he really should check out Sire too.

10 Likes

Why stop there, book him a ticket to Japan! :rofl:

8 Likes

*Her, and how I wish :rofl: Being an eternal student working odd jobs really isn’t conducive to the goal of a nice bass collection

4 Likes

My apologies for assuming your gender.

Um, how much longer before you graduate with enough qualifications to get a full-time job?

Whilst the Japan reference, was mildly flippant, @howard posted an awesome thread on here a while back about shopping for basses there. As well as the incredible, and I mean incredible, selection of instruments the Yen is extremely weak against the USD and GBP (go on, tell me you’re not American or British now!), which makes the prices of some things comically cheap.

Here’s the thread:

And here’s the thread of what happened when I went to Japan last month; of potential interest to you is the photos in my third post in the thread, which you can use to compare the prices with what you see at home:

1 Like

Great question.

I started with an ibanez GS200 (or something like this), playbility was super nice but I was not a fan of the sound / multiplicity of choice (active / passive, pick up blend, tone controls…)

went for the PBasss Squier CV 70 and felt in love with it (sound, playability…), it does the job and the finish is great + it fits very well to many songs (without having to wonder which button should be turned to which level for the bass to sound good… it does it 90% of time)

I’m sure that with more experience, I could play around to have the Ibanez bass sound as I like … which is Pbass sound :wink:

1 Like

Yikes! Very sorry! I shouldn’t have assumed.

3 Likes

Both are great choice, but I feel like yours is more a question of what do you want to play rather than wich do you want to choose. This is pretty much a question of a classic vs a modern instrument. I used to own the TRBX305, it was a fine tool for metal but was a very agressive sounding instrument. I switched to a TRBX 605 because of that (the alnico pickup are way more well rounded for most any genre).

2 Likes

It sounds like that is the one that excites you more. So it is more likely to be the better fit for you.

(I’d take a BB434, but that’s me.)

4 Likes

If you’re only gonna have one, my vote would always be a Pbass.

1 Like

The BroadBass is such a nice bass indeed. I owned a BB434M from 2017 up to last year, it is a gem.

3 Likes

Then definitely leave me out if the convo :rofl:

10 Likes

Best answer: if you can, try both and see which one connects with you more.

If you can’t try them, think about the kind of sound you’ve been playing lately.

And I agree with everyone who said that at some point you’ll probably end up having both — not necessarily these exact models, but this type of instrument.

2 Likes