HELP! JJ vs PJ (DiMarzio DP305N/DP302N vs DP126)

In fact this one was very high on my list. I really like the sound!

But I watched the LowendLobster video a few months ago … and it is a really big short scale that might not resolve my shoulder issues by the looks of it (LowendLobster compares the size to a 34"…)
I cannot play it here in Hamburg, and the online stores are (rightfully) fed up with me sending back basses all the time.

So I’ll pass on that one!

I lost a lot of respect for Lobster over that.

TV Jones makes pickups that fit the G2220; in fact I believe they were the pickups on the original model years ago

1 Like

Why? I think it is great to unmask the marketing promisses when they sell something that it isn’t!?

Yeah … I read about the TV Jones Humbuckers. So that would be ideal … but you can’t get them in Germany, and I really want to listen to them and have the option to return…

Well if it’s short you want and a Jazz bass. Here you go at a giveaway price :wink:

2 Likes

I think he went way overboard on it. And I think he did it for clicks, And I generally have been supportive of Lobster

2 Likes

The guy shouldn’t be taken seriously for reviews but I have to admit he was right a out the 2220. The thing is - its stock single coils sound better than stock Fender pups :rofl:

I think it is a good sounding bass and the controversy was way overblown for sure. I would definitely not have returned one over that as it sounds good for what it is.

2 Likes

This is the first time I don’t agree with you!
For me it’s the opposite: when I saw his videos the first time, I was like: “WTF?”.
I dismissed them after 30 seconds - but I was wrong!

Now I have seen quite a few and I enjoy the mixture of nerdiness, serious information and great playing!

I appreciated him finding out about the fake humbuckers too.
I think it is outrageous what Gretsch did, but I am very sensitive about fake marketing/sales, cause I always need to verify vendor information on a technical level in my job. They always try to f#ck me, and not in a good way…

his reviews are often laughably hot takes. Hearing that Lobster disliked something bothers me not at all.

His other videos are entertaining and he seems like a great guy.

1 Like

Did he do a bad review about a Yamaha? :slight_smile:

I don’t think it was outrageous, I think it was a goof. Gretsch owned up to it, made good to those who bought it and was unhappy, and did the right thing.

It’s a good quality, good sounding, $300 bass. The mistake is out of character for the company, and yes point it out and get it taken care of, but it was blown all out of proportion.

1 Like

Yes, and also a dingwall and some other excellent Squiers and Fenders. The Yamaha one was especially bad as the bass seemed to just need a pickup height adjustment based on his criticism, which otherwise was only basically “I don’t like how it sounds with my favorite strings”.

The dingwall he ended up modding to sound like his Jazz bass. This should literally be prosecutable as a crime :rofl:

2 Likes

He did a bad review of the BB735…

2 Likes

yup, widely regarded as a top tier instrument. Except on Lobster World.

Also slammed were the Steve Harris Signature (ditto), the Dingwall Combustion (ditto), and there was one that irritated John but I forget which (maybe an Aerodyne?) that he panned.

tl;dr, if Lobster hated it there’s a solid, solid chance I will love it :slight_smile:

2 Likes

Sometimes it’s a matter of … taste!

But again, when it comes to technical features, information MUST be correct!

Otherwise: @Wombat-metal - I am happy to sell you some stuff. If it is different from what I told you, consider it a “goof” :slight_smile:

Gretsch and their owner company Fender are not in the habit of making false claims. They don’t have a history of it, quite the opposite. Call them out on it? Sure. Pitchforks and torches? Bit much.

2 Likes

Ahh yeah, IIRC John’s trigger was it was the Squier Classic Vibe ‘70s that he shat all over and gave two claws :rofl:

That thing felt as good as Fender Players to me. Great bass for the price.

2 Likes

I am actually trying to remember ever agreeing with him. Hmm, he likes Sires, and hates the Gold Foil things. I am down with those :slight_smile:

And to be clear, I like him and his content a lot, just not his “reviews”, which are much closer to personal taste than objective evaluation. Which, for a bass channel, I don’t need to see.

I have no disagreement with you about the sound of the Gretsch! I like it too!

But again: if I’m told it’s a duck, I expect to get a duck - no matter how good it quacks :slight_smile:

1 Like

If you like the sound, and liked the feel, and liked the looks, I would suggest you cancel the HB order and buy another Junior Jet :slight_smile:

1 Like

I knew what you would say when I wrote this :slight_smile:

I will wait for the HB, try it … and if it’s bad I’ll shoot it!