Personally, I’m a “pie guy”. Cake just doesn’t do it for me. I mean, some are ok, like a dulce-de-leche cake with butter cream frosting, but generally I’d rather have a nice apple pie than cake any day.
4 Likes
Pie can include pizza. 
7 Likes
As a kid, I always asked my mother for a birthday apple pie instead of a cake.
I like cake. I love a really good apple pie any day of the week.
4 Likes
Like both, prefer pie 
Pecan pie, sweet potato pie, and pumpkin pie would be my faves, in order. Then blackberry and apple close behind.
And don’t forget about good southern-style cobbler.
4 Likes
Whatever peach cobbler is, that is my favorite.
For cake I like Boston cream pie.
For pie I like Apple.
6 Likes
Cake all the way! I like savory pies.
5 Likes
Normally, cake. But if the wife is baking a cherry pie, then forget the cake!
5 Likes
Both.
Pizza is considered Pie in the NorthEastern USA so I need to include that too
4 Likes
pie and cake are actually synonyms
3 Likes
Just wheel over the pastry cart. 
4 Likes
Pi!
Key Lime Pie.
And 3.14.
8 Likes
Man, now I want some pecan pie. With some ice cream.
4 Likes
Tiramisu or creme brulee for me. In the absence of those, whatever is on the dessert cart. Pie or cake? Whatever. Why limit yourself to one or the other?
6 Likes
I see what you did there.
Exactly!
7 Likes
It’s a question of which is your preference; which you would choose if presented with both cake and pie as options.
6 Likes
This. I like this Eric guy more and more.
8 Likes
Exactly this 
It would depend on what kind of pie(s) and what kind of cake(s) are being offered.
(I wonder if there’s such a thing as tofu pie or cake)
4 Likes
