@craig.lox
More to your queston about differences between P and Jazz basses that I did not see clarified in the. other thread. All I saw was “there are slight differences between body shape”, which is true, but it is a huge deciding factor to what type of bass it is and what it says on the head stock.
The reason an Aerodyne is a Jazz bass P/J style is because it has a Jazz Body.
The basses like Duff signature is called a P bass P/J, because it has a P bass body. so the bass is always called what the body is, and then described as P/J if it is a combo, and is also often called MODIFIED. So Aerodyne would be a Modified Jazz P/J and Duff would be Modified P bass P/J.
About necks and pick ups, that has been covered already.
Jazz basses are good for Metal cuz they cut thru the mix, but there are no set rules.
Thanks @T_dub I never connected those dots. That is very helpful.
As far as metal, Steve Harris of Iron Maiden uses a good old P bass, while Ian Hill of Judas Priest started out with a Jazz. Frank Bello of Anthrax uses a PJ. People try to make it seem like there are rules, and certainly manufacturers do trying to sell you a “metal” (or whatever genre they’re targetting), but a bass can produce a wide variety of tones. I posted a song a couple weeks ago where a punk band used a Beatle bass and it sounded great.
Yeah, Jazz being good for metal, I get from Glen Fricker, cuz he produces metal and says the mids are good to cut thru, but he doesn’t mandate that. he more mandates, you know the song, and the bass stays in tune, once he gets a dry track from a bass that was in tune, he can manipulate it however he wants it to sound (for the most part)
And I followed it with “there are no set rules” And if your bass alone can’t cut thru on a metal tune, there are pedals, amps, preamps and amp and cab sims, and EQ’s that can make it, so just be like LEMMY, and play what you think looks cool, as he said, I can make anything sound like whatever I want it too, but I can’t make ugly look great.
Well, he was ugly and great, maybe it was “can’t make ugly beautiful.”
People (myself included) obsess way too much over the tone of the instrument itself. You’d be surprised how much you can change the tone in the DAW.
For me, at this point, feel is by far the most important, followed by a tie between tone and looks. I can make the tone do what I want after recording it. Much harder to fix looks, and feel is critical